When my age was in the single digits, in the 1940’s and 1950’s, Jews were only beginning to become accepted in America. One of the jokes a young Jew like me often heard regarding a Jewish man was: “He’s a great friend of mine…but I wouldn’t want him to marry my daughter. When thinking about Ben Carson’s surging to the lead in the Iowa polling and trying to figure out why, I thought of that hoary joke from my youth.
As the 50’s went on, many young Black comedians adopted that joke, but with a Black protagonist. What that joke was speaking to, was something that you would commonly hear among American White racists, especially those who had interactions with Black people in their daily lives. It was the meme that Black people in general were exactly like the negative racial stereotypes that these racists believed, but that some Blacks weren’t “like the rest of them”. To wit: stupid. lazy, oversexed and shiftless. If you are aware of the history of bigotry in the United States, the same absurd stereotypes were at one time, or another, applied to the Jewish, Irish, Italian, Latino and Asian immigrants that flooded this country in waves throughout the 19th and 20th Centuries. When Donald Trump speaks of Mexican immigrants coming here and raping women, he is using this same old, disgusting racist stereotype and as we have seen it meets the approval of a large minority of Americans.
Whatever one thinks of the policies of Barack Obama, anyone with a level of intelligence above the dim, must realize that the vitriol hurled upon him wasn’t about his policy positions alone. Obama has probably been the President most disrespected by a significant portion of our population, since Abraham Lincoln was heaped with opprobrium throughout the traitorous Southern States of our nation. The insane “Birther” movement, lacked the courage to admit that it was a racist movement attempting to de-legitimize a Black man, who had the effrontery to run for and win the American Presidency. I’ve written much about the racist nature of our country, which you can find if you click here and enter “racism” in the search function. You can also find more here at ElephantTail if you click on the search function above. In fact I’m in the process of restoring all of my lost writing on racism, but have yet to complete the task. My purpose in mentioning my writing, is to make it clear that I believe that the amount of bigotry that exists in this country, particularly against people of color, goes beyond overt racism and is intertwined with a sense of “White Privilege”. Given this, I’m sure people would think it hard for me to explain why so many in the racist Republican Party are so excited about Ben Carson and his candidacy? My explanation goes back to the lame joke I started with.
The Civil Rights movement has accomplished much in my lifetime and yet has many miles to travel to really end the cancer of racism that pervades our system and skews it against people of color. A good part of the reason for that is the Republican Party, in the 1968 Presidential election, unveiled a strategy that revived racism and allowed this Party to hold the Presidency for 28, of the last 47 years. This policy was the so-called “Southern Strategy”, that allowed an unlikable candidate like Richard Nixon to win the White House, twice, the second time in a landslide victory. That strategy was of course appealing to the racists, who were stunned by the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Bill, which seemingly ended “Jim Crow”. What the Civil Rights Movement did was to basically make it socially unacceptable to be overtly racist in normal social discourse. What it hadn’t done was eliminate the prejudice that existed in many Americans, or even the sense of “White Privilege” that existed in most of America’s “Whites,” including many liberals. The effects of hundreds of years, with a dominant theme of unequal status to people of color and their exploitation, cannot suddenly be eradicated by the passage of any legislation.
So Nixon’s “Southern Strategy” was to appeal to the innate Racism of many in this country by the use of coded language. “Crime” and “drugs” became code words denoting Black people even though percentage wise, just as many “White” people, as “Black” people engaged in both. By using code, Nixon was able to reassure the Southerners, still mourning their loss of “Jim Crow,” that he was on their side. His victory marked the beginning of the Republican landslide in the South, that continues to this day.
Now the elimination of “Jim Crow”, at least as public policy, had some interesting effects, perhaps unforeseen in those who wrote the 1964 Bill. Football in the South, or Southern type States like Texas and Oklahoma, is king. This is particularly true of High School and College Football, because it dovetails with local and regional pride. Ending segregation meant that the Southern College powers needed to recruit Black stars to remain relevant in the national football ratings. How does someone of racist bent, cheer on the hero of their football team if they are Black? They do it by depicting that hero as being “special”, not like those other Blacks who are sub-human. If their hero comes from modest circumstances, they praise his ability to “rise above” his presumably “bad” background and so become “somewhat” White. It becomes the “some of my best friends are…….” syndrome once again. The premise behind it being that even though most Blacks are less human than Whites, a few are able to be like “Whites”, or almost like White’s, enough to be considered roughly equal. Which brings me back to the support of Ben Carson.
One cannot deny the impressive narrative of Dr. Carson’s life. He is clearly an extraordinary Physician and Surgeon. Yet when it comes to areas outside of medicine, I think Dr. Carson leaves something to be desired. Chris Weigart in Huffpost writes about Carson in “Not Exactly Brain Surgery”: “Carson has two go-to comparisons that he’ll deploy on any number of unrelated current issues: either America is going the way of the Nazis, or we’re headed back to slavery. Those are pretty extreme examples to use, but they’re both favorites of Carson, used by him on a routine basis. So far, this has been what the media has chosen to focus on when dissecting Carson’s campaign.
This is a shame, because Carson has a flaw which is even bigger. His over-the-top Nazi and slavery comparisons actually play pretty well with the Republican primary audience, no matter how many times the pundits raise their metaphorical eyebrows over them. But what is harder to explain is the absolute incoherence of pretty much all of Carson’s policy positions. Not unlike Trump, Carson seems satisfied with vague ideas heavy on ideology and sloganeering, but very light on actual details. But unlike Trump, Carson gets pretty flustered whenever anyone asks him about the missing details. Trump just bulls his way through any doubts interviewers have, but Carson can’t really pull off the same trick. What happens instead is that he melts down.”
Actually, what Weigart writes of was what has actually puzzled me since I saw Carson on the Republican debates. Let’s forget for a moment what Carson was actually saying and focus on his facial affect and his manner of saying it. What I saw was someone with a “flat” affect, talking slowly and monotonically, with more than a hint of having to exert tremendous control to keep from falling apart. In short, forgetting his politics, he impressed me a a person who was either mentally unstable, or heavily medicated, or possibly even recovering from a stroke. He is far from an inspirational speaker and his manner shows little that would evoke passion in anyone.
I think Carson has risen in the polls because he exemplifies what many racists believe, which is that a few individual Black people can actually be equal to Whites. His fame as a “Brain Surgeon” ensure his credentials for intelligence and his political leanings ensure their own political leanings are endorsed, nay extolled, by a Black man no less. When he says really stupid things to the effect that had Jews been armed, they would have prevented the Holocaust, he is reinforcing their own reverent beliefs in the use of weaponry to protect themselves. That he, a demonstrably intelligent Black man, is making this ridiculous point, of course begs the question that underlying most of their need for weaponry is their own fear of Black people. That is what makes him so appealing to them. Carson is a Black man, a brain surgeon, who believes as they do that what is holding Black success back in this country is Blacks own lack of effort to succeed. By Carson’s success, he becomes living proof of the laziness and shiftlessness of most Black people. Carson gives succor to those holding up Ben Carson as the exception, proving the rule that people of color are really to blame for their own problems.
Now one could point out that this wasn’t deemed to be true for Barack Obama, about whom the racist venom in the country has been allowed to be spread in public commentary that we haven’t seen since the days of “Jim Crow”. That Obama was a Harvard Law School Graduate and editor of the most prestigious law review in this country, was dismissed as being undeserved. That he was a citizen of the United States was disputed. That he was even a Christian was called into question. The difference between Obama and Carson is clearly that Obama doesn’t believe in what the racists believe in and thus was really one of those Blacks not to be trusted.
In the last Republican primary, there was a Black man Herman Cain carrying the racist standard and for a while he was also a front runner. Ben Carson is this years Republican Herman Cain. Carson will not get the nomination and I doubt that he would be the nominee’s Vice Presidential choice. To paraphrase that hoary old joke: “Some of my favorite candidates are Black…..but I wouldn’t want one running the country.
October 27, 2015 at 11:27 pm
I think you’re a pompous bigot.
LikeLike
October 27, 2015 at 11:31 pm
I mean do you actually think that prejudice is only in Republicans? Do you actually think many Democrats who voted for Obama don’t fit the same stereotype you just penned in your title?
LikeLike
October 28, 2015 at 12:07 am
Franky,
White Privilege is not limited to political parties. However, Nixon was elected directly because of racism in the South. As far as Carson goes, my opinion is that he is either crazy, or drugged.
So let me ask, do you think the Holocaust would never have happened if the Jews in Germany were armed? One would have to be crazy, or drugged to believe that was even possible and Carson does believe just that.
LikeLike
October 28, 2015 at 12:12 am
franky,
I don’t recall Mike saying anything about whether Democrats would feel the same way. Are you projecting?
Is this another case of blogging while intoxicated (BWI)?
You seem excessively belligerent. We can do belligerent, if you’d like.
LikeLike
October 28, 2015 at 1:02 pm
http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2015/10/ben-carson-seventh-day-adventist-evangelical-voters-Iowa Carson seems to be getting the evangelical vote as Huckabee and Santorum fade away but in the end will voters accept a Seventh Day Adventist with extreme beliefs. I doubt it. He would probably carry very few states in the general. Trump has become the candidate of non evangelical republicans, and he is starting to question Carson’s extreme religious beliefs.
LikeLike
October 28, 2015 at 1:03 pm
Bob K, Sounds like franky is carrying a resentment from one of the other blogs.
LikeLike
October 28, 2015 at 2:21 pm
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/24/opinion/charles-blow-the-soft-bigotry-of-ben-carson.html “Carson knows that his outrageous antics in his role as the anti-Obama are a most profitable enterprise. He mixes political critique with Christian theological messaging to rake in quite a bit of money on the lecture circuit. As Politico reported in July, Carson “brought in nearly $2 million delivering inspirational speeches to faith-based groups like Christian high schools and pregnancy centers in 2014,” with speaking fees ranging “from $12,320 to $48,500.”
This is a sad turn — spurred, I believe, by profit motive — for such a great legacy.
I, like many other African-Americans, had come to see Carson as a hero before his foray into politics because of the resonance of his personal story — a poor inner-city child being raised by a driven single mother who valued education and instilled in him a sense of character that would allow him to become a staggering success.
Carson was the embodiment of possibility. His 1990 book, “Gifted Hands,” was required reading for many young people.
But as a political figure, his stature is diminished as he reveals himself to be intolerant, bordering on soft bigotry, and also reckless and needlessly inflammatory. No one can discount what Carson accomplished professionally, but those accomplishments must now stand shoulder to shoulder with this new persona: whisper-soft purveyor of hyperbolic hucksterism.”
LikeLike
October 28, 2015 at 2:51 pm
This has some of the same characteristics of the Sarah Palin movement.
LikeLike
October 28, 2015 at 3:19 pm
SWM,
Yah, I can’t keep up with all of these aliases. Some of these folks seem to need a witness protection program, every time they switch blogs.
“Hey, guess who I used to be!”
“Why?”
You’re probably right. Franky’s abrupt, over-the-top hostility does suggest a prior, losing relationship with Mike.
Perhaps resuming the medication schedule would help?
LikeLike
October 28, 2015 at 4:07 pm
I am currently reading The New Jim Crow by Michelle Alexander. I think this book is a must read. What she argues in this book resonates with a recent Atlantic article on Mass Incarceration and the Black Family. Alexander begins by noting how systemic racism is not inconsistent with electing a black president or the success of Oprah Winfrey. This book is eye-opening without being sensationalistic or suggesting that there is an easy fix. Changing the system will require hard work.
LikeLike
October 28, 2015 at 4:10 pm
franky: Democrats are demonstrably, by statistics, much less racist than Republicans; in fact a Republican is more than twice as likely to agree with both overt and subtle racist stereotypes than a Democrat, even after controlling for socioeconomic status, age and gender.
You don’t do yourself any favors by denying reality. Republican policies attract racists. For example, there are non-racist reasons to be opposed to liberal immigration or amnesty for illegal immigrants, but there are also racist reasons to be opposed, and thus many racists vote for Republican that are promising to enact their racist agenda (for whatever reason).
LikeLike
October 28, 2015 at 4:52 pm
Ian,
I’ll check out that book because what you describe does resonate with me. The “War on Drugs” for instance, which has led to the mass incarceration of black people for essentially victimless “crimes”, is really a new form of Jim Crow. In fact Jim Crow and segregation never really went away, the bigots just adjusted their racist policies.
LikeLike
October 28, 2015 at 4:54 pm
Franky does seem to be familiar with me from other sites. If he is though, he should be familiar with the fact that I’m hardly a partisan Democrat and have spent much time castigating Democrat’s policies, the Clintons and Barack Obama
LikeLike
October 29, 2015 at 12:52 am
How can you say that about Ben Carson? Even media moguls like Rupert Murdoch think Ben would “properly” address the racial divide.
Now I’ll try to find out what Dick Cheney thinks of him.
LikeLike
October 29, 2015 at 3:45 am
So, is the point that there are simply more racist Republicans than Democrats? If so, I would agree. But the percentages are much closer than any of you could/would admit. I would put the percentage differential in single digits.
LikeLike
October 29, 2015 at 2:48 pm
“So, is the point that there are simply more racist Republicans than Democrats? If so, I would agree. But the percentages are much closer than any of you could/would admit.”
Franky,
You’re accusing me of a position that I haven’t taken. Let me be clear: When it comes to people of color, White America is generally racist. This is not a new position. I’ve written it here: https://miconoclast.wordpress.com/2015/08/24/americas-black-problem-isnt-a-black-problem/
I’ve also written about it here: https://miconoclast.wordpress.com/2015/10/25/a-further-explanation-of-the-blindness-of-white-privilege-2/
What I’m clearly stating though, in this piece, is that while racism directed at people of color exists all across the board in the U.S., the Republican Party uses it to get elected. Now many of the Republican persuasion might counter that Democrats use the idea of racism to get Black votes and there is some validity to that. However, when you have one party that denies the reality of America’s racism (Republicans) and another that admits there is racism (Democrats), who would you vote for if you were a person of color?
LikeLike
October 29, 2015 at 2:49 pm
Pete,
Well if Rupert Murdoch thinks Carson is okay…..who am I to argue?
LikeLike
November 4, 2015 at 4:45 pm
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/cafe/why-ben-carson-is-no-herman-cain “So there remains what should actually disqualify Carson: his extremist, paranoid “world-view” which treats regular boring old center-left liberals as conscious and systematically deceitful would-be destroyers of this country bent on imposing a Marxist tyranny via “politically correct” suppression of free speech and confiscation of guns.
There’s unquestionably a constituency for this point of view, but we may never know whether it would outnumber the Republicans baffled or horrified by it until such time as one of his rivals or the heretofore clueless media start talking about it. If they don’t pretty soon, then one theory of the 2016 GOP nominating process could come true: conservatives want to rerun the 1964 elections, and they’ve finally found their Barry Goldwater.”
LikeLike
November 4, 2015 at 5:15 pm
SwM,
Another point about Carson which should frighten most of us is that in his Seventh Day Adventist orthodoxy he believes that the world will end in our lifetime. Hence, why worry about climate change?
A story yesterday about a Texas homeschooling couple who are suing to keep authorities from requiring that they teach anything to their 5 year old. Their reasoning: With the “rapture” coming soon, why not just let him play and be innocent?
LikeLike
November 4, 2015 at 6:58 pm
I have a good friend who is republican, yes, sadly, many of my friends are republicans, at any rate; this particular good friend was going to support Carson in the primaries until she found out he believes all children should be vaccinated. Well, that ended her support for him.
I kid you not.
LikeLike